Quantcast
Channel: Comments on: The Elegance of the Hedgehog, by Muriel Barbery
Browsing all 10 articles
Browse latest View live

By: Isabel

Both of her novels are going to be read for our book club. I’ll let you know what we think.

View Article



By: KevinfromCanada

Interesting that you are reading them both, Isabel — have you decided in what order? One aspect that I think your book club in New Orleans will bring to the table is the French background which is very...

View Article

By: Isabel

It’s funny how it happened. One member selected Hedgehog, another nominated Gourmet. We were supposed to read Gourmet for the April meeting, but the meeting was cancelled. So, we are discussing both in...

View Article

By: Sasha

I gave in. The book was too brand-spanking-new and shiny and it just beckoned me. Dammit. Now that I own it–paid money for it!–I expect it to knock my socks off, haha.

View Article

By: Michael Levin

A deeply pretentious book. The author is no novelist. She just puts her own thoughts into the mouths of a young girl and a middle-aged concierge. Do people really like this book? I suspect they pretend...

View Article


By: KevinfromCanada

Michael: You are certainly entitled to your opinion, but I think it might be a bit harsh. After all, don’t novelists put thoughts in the mouths of their characters by definition? And while I was...

View Article

By: Guy Savage

I wished the novel had concentrated more on the housekeeper. I had a more difficult time with the child-narrator. I gave my copy to a friend who absolutely loved it.

View Article

By: KevinfromCanada

Guy: I have to admit I don’t remember much about this book — delighted to hear you found a good home for your copy. Obviously, there are readers who really like the book and more power to them.

View Article


By: Guy Savage

The author had a really generous, positive world vision for this book, and that seems to be some of its appeal.

View Article


By: Andrea

My mother gave me Hedgehog to read. She loved it; I didn’t, for many of the same reasons you give. One mistake in your review: the Mr. Ozu who moves in is not the filmmaker Ozu whose oeuvre Renee loves...

View Article
Browsing all 10 articles
Browse latest View live




Latest Images